Follow Us @blacksheepbagelsnf Sun-Mon: 6:30AM - 3PM
  • En

Where Bagels are

Just the Beginning

Black Sheep Bagels Logo

North Forks Go-to Spot, Eat Like a Local

At Black Sheep Bagels we pride ourselves in using only the highest quality ingredients to craft the most delicious bagels and sandwiches.
Everything is made with love from our traditional style boiled and baked bagels to our hot cinnabuns, egg sandwiches, acai bowls, and much much more.

Check out our grab and go section for when you're in a hurry featuring breakfast and lunch items such as parfaits, our famous overnight oats, green salads, lunch wraps, fresh fruit and more.

Here at black sheep bagels we refuse to cut corners when it comes to quality food, so you can always expect to leave satisfied and full.
We are always innovating our menu to keep it fun and exciting.
From the moment you walk through the door, you will feel the love and vibes from our friendly staff.

Proudly Serving Hampton Coffee. Make it an iced coffee with our Famous Iced Coffee Cubes.
Hampton Coffee

  • Indoor and Outdoor Seating Available

Serving Breakfast and Lunch ALL DAY.

Visit or Contact us

Locations

Jamesport Location

1451 Main Rd, Jamesport, NY 11947


Call:

(631) 779-2914

Open Hours:

Every Day:
6:30AM – 3PM





Cutchogue Location

31000 Main Rd, Cutchogue, NY, 11935 USA


Call:

(631) 735-9998

Open Hours:

Every Day:
6:30AM – 3PM

Testimonials

What they're saying about us

Best bagels on the North Fork. This is our go to spot whether we have guests in town or are looking for a few bagels for the house. They’re always soft and fresh and are still good the next day. The service is friendly and fast and I’m never waiting more than five or ten minutes no matter busy it is.

Thomas P

Recommended dishes Everything, Bacon Egg and Cheese on Sesame, Egg Everything

Having lived in NY prior, we always look for new bagel places each visit. Black Sheep is the best - we all agreed. And the bagels are huge with overly generous cream cheese. A must stop if you are out on the North Fork!! Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 Recommended dishes Everything

Chris Ainsworth

Recommended dishes Everything

I love this place more. I’ll never eat another bagel outside of Long Island again. We got crumb cake, Cinnabons, jalapeño bagel, and coffee!!!!!

Natalie Mamrol

Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5

Food was amazing, beyond amazing!

Joshua Holten

Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5

Hands-down, the absolute best sandwiches on the north fork of Long Island! Impeccable service, and a sense of urgency behind the counter that you don’t see much out here! The bagels are great, always fresh, and I highly recommend the paninis (namely, as shown in the photo: The Hobo-Lini - consisting of bacon, egg, cheese, and a hash brown pressed on a bagel)!

Matthew “Matt from the North Fork” Chizever

Recommends Bagels and Paninis

I am so happy my host recommended Chris. I was filming a movie in Mattituck and Chris provided lunch for my cast and crew every day (8 days). The food is healthy and delicious. He also accommodated my vegetarians. Thank you!

Tatiana Sokolova

Healthy Options

Delicious bagels especially the specialty ones! Favorite is cheddar jalapeño bacon with cream cheese. So good.

Evan T

Second time having Black Sheep Bagels and both times was very impressed. The iced coffee is served with coffee iced cubes! Won’t get watered down, I love it! The bagels are also great! Definitely give it a try! Also the have bagel cannolis! They’re pretty good

Charles F

Recommended dishes Bagel Bombs, Everything

Charles f