Welcome to
Black Sheep Bagels

Where Bagels Are Just The Beginning

About Us

We strive for Quality and Excellence in Customer service

  • Every type of bagel fresh made every day
  • Your favorite spreads and Toppings
  • Serving Long Island NY at Two Locations, Jamesport and Cutchogue

Online Menu

Click or Scan Barcode for online Menu


Welcoming Guests for Breakfast and Lunch for a Sandwich and Coffee. Choose from our wide selection of:

  • Bagels fresh made every day
  • Breakfast Sandwiches
  • Lunch Sandwiches
  • Pastries
  • Acai Bowls
  • Catering

Contact us


Phone: (631) 779-2914
EMail: [email protected]


Phone: (631) 735-9998



Phone: (631) 779-2914
Address: 1451 Main Rd, Jamesport, NY 11947

Phone: (631) 735-9998
Address: 31000 Main Rd, Cutchogue, NY 11935


  • Monday 6:30AM–3PM
  • Tuesday 6:30AM–3PM
  • Wednesday 6:30AM–3PM
  • Thursday 6:30AM–3PM
  • Friday 6:30AM–3PM
  • Saturday 6:30AM–3PM
  • Sunday 6:30AM–3PM

JamesPort Location

Address: Black Sheep Bagels
        1451 Main Rd,
        Jamesport, NY 11947

Cutchogue Location Now Opened

Address: Black Sheep Bagels
        31000 Main Rd,
        Cutchogue, NY 11935


* We are required to collect NYS sales Tax
* Prices may vary and are subject to change